C-Shore Communications Inc
  • Home
  • About
  • Services
  • Contact
Select Page

The art of asking the public their opinion, part three (BC Ferries)

by Carla Shore | Feb 10, 2016 | Messaging | 0 comments

Asking the public for their thoughts can be a great way of creating meaningful two–way engagement for your organization. It can also be a good marketing tool to use a contest to name something new, bringing your organization to the attention of the public and getting them involved in the company. But if you haven’t thought through what you’ll get when you ask, you could get disastrous results.

I’ve already shown you how British Gas messed up their attempt at engagement with a badly timed Twitter town hall, and how the Northwest Territories of Canada asked the public if they should be renamed and almost ended up being called “Bob.” Here is my final example in this series from my home province of British Columbia.

CF4awijWMAE_radProving that you need to consider the impact of engagement as part of your entire communications strategy is the story of BC Ferries. In a stroke of ‘genius’, the ferry corporation asked the public to suggest a name for its new class of boats. For another company, this might have been a strong campaign, but the BC public was pretty ticked off at a series of price hikes and service cuts by BC Ferries, so this engagement left the organization wide open to parody.

In May 2015, the ferry corporation opened a contest for new names for three intermediate class ferries, and offered a $500 prize. After only a few days, the public had submitted a lot of suggestions that, well, didn’t meet the organization’s naming criteria. Some of the ideas submitted (and talked about on social media!):

  • Spirit of The WalletSucker
  • Queen of No Other Choice
  • The Spirit of Unfettered Capitalism
  • Queen of the Cash Cow
  • HMS Overdraft
  • Coastal Fair Hike
  • Spirit of Bad WiFi
  • HMS Cantafford
  • MV Sailing Wait
  • Queen of the Damned
  • Coastal Desperation

The Vancouver Sun noted that this contest was a fascinating peek into how the public viewed the ferry corporation:

…interesting to muse on how a public that once doted on a ferry system that helped define its collective identity has since arrived at the place from which it now sees it as a service to be mercilessly mocked as a symbol of over-priced ineptitude.

The marketing folks at the ferry corporation have been keeping a stiff upper lip over the keel-hauling, hoping the publicity will attract greater attention to the contest, a Twitter-era spin on that hoary print media proverb that there’s no such thing as bad publicity and it doesn’t matter what they print about you as they spell your name right.

In the end, the contest proceeded and the new ferries were called Salish Orca, Salish Eagle and Salish Raven. But since so many British Columbians saw this contest as another way to air their beefs about high prices and service problems, it was not a good exercise in engagement for BC Ferries.

BC Ferries should have found a way to recover from this mockery and take control of the messages coming out of this contest. They could have used some of the complaints in an announcement of a change in service, such as a new onboard menu, or improved WIFI service, showing that they were responsive to public opinion.

Or they could have gone in on the joke, gently poking fun at themselves by compiling their own list of top ten suggestions they would not be using. BC Ferries is not known for their sense of humour, but this might have been a lost opportunity to show a sense of deprecation that may have improved how the public responded to the organization. Instead, it was just a fizzle of a contest where those outside the organization, instead of BC Ferries themselves, controlled the messaging.

Today’s lesson: If your operations are not in the public favour, yet you open yourself up to very public input, get ready to laugh along with the commentary or have messaging ready that can respond to whatever the public throws at you.

Submit a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *





Categories

  • Apologies
  • Avoiding questions
  • Bad marketing ideas
  • Bad publicity
  • Bad taste
  • Be physically prepared
  • Conflict of Interest
  • Crisis Communications
  • Email screw ups
  • Ethics
  • Gum chewing
  • Internet is forever
  • Messaging
  • Photo Opps
  • Pitching media
  • Reacting to questioning
  • Social media screw ups
  • Trust and Lies
  • Uncategorized
  • Unwanted endorsements

Recent Posts

  • Newsbots are quietly taking over our feeds …should we be concerned? What does this mean for PR?
  • Do you lose your counter culture cred if everyone can own your exclusive product?
  • Targeting women doesn’t just mean turning it pink
  • The art of asking the public their opinion, part three (BC Ferries)
  • The art of asking the public their opinion, part two (NWT as Bob?)

Learn More

  • Home
  • About
  • Services
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

News

Carla Shore delivered a workshop on “Bullied online for doing our jobs” at the annual conference of the Canadian Public Relations Society, Transformations 2020.

What People Say

"Carla's communications background coupled with her writing skills proved to be an invaluable asset as the VSB worked through several very critical issues directly impacting the school district. Carla's ability to manage the complexity of the VSB communications demonstrates a proven skill set."

Guy Bonnefoy, Interim Secretary Treasurer, Vancouver School Board
"Carla did an outstanding job managing communications for the Commission in a difficult role. I benefited from her issues management, skills at media relations, & media training. She also served as the commission's bilingual spokesperson & her professionalism in this role was evident."

Brian Wallace QC, Senior Commission Counsel, Cohen Commission of Inquiry into the Decline of the Sockeye Salmon in the Fraser River
"We were so impressed with the organization, writing and advice we got to promote BC Buy Local Week. Carla and her team ensured our news conference went smoothly, and the media coverage of the week was a huge success."

Katja Macura, LOCO BC
"I continue to be impressed with the way Carla understands how communications fits in to our organization, and the ways she helps us achieve our goals using a variety of communications techniques. Her leadership skills in working with other members of our team are also a big asset to our organization."

Jennifer Johnstone, President & CEO, Central City Foundation
"I was very impressed by how quickly Carla brought herself up to speed on my business and was able to articulate in written material recommendations for my audience. She was also on time and on budget. What more can anyone ask for!"

Susan Stiene, Director, Retail & Passenger Services, YVR Vancouver Airport Authority
"What impressed me the most about Carla was her ability to manage multiple projects and priorities without missing her deadlines, and the speed at which she performed her assignments. Carla is a very strong communicator and project manager."

Susan Schooley, Manager, Consultations, Marketing and Communications, Western Economic Diversification Canada
"Wonderful job, Carla. Thank heavens we had you on this project. You are more than an asset."

David Kuefler, Junxion Strategies
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Website by Jamie Leigh | Copyright C-Shore Communications Inc